Valet Parking Insurance: What Every Property Should Know
Understanding valet parking insurance protects your property, your guests, and your business. A comprehensive guide to garage-keeper liability, coverage types, and risk management.
When a guest hands their car keys to a valet attendant, they're trusting that company with a $30,000 to $100,000 asset. That trust requires the right insurance coverage behind it. Whether you're a property manager evaluating valet providers or a venue owner considering adding valet service, understanding insurance is essential.
Why Valet Insurance Matters
Valet parking creates specific liability scenarios that standard business insurance doesn't cover:
- Vehicle damage — a scratched bumper, a curbed wheel, or a collision in the lot
- Theft — a vehicle or its contents going missing during valet custody
- Property damage — an attendant damages a bollard, gate arm, or another parked car
- Third-party injury — a pedestrian or other driver involved in an incident
- Key loss — the cost of replacing modern electronic key fobs can exceed $500
Without proper insurance, these incidents become your problem — even if you hired a valet company to handle parking.
For related property management considerations, see our article on gated community valet services.
Types of Valet Insurance Coverage
Garage-Keeper Liability
This is the cornerstone of valet insurance. Garage-keeper liability covers damage to vehicles while they're in the valet company's care, custody, and control.
What it covers:
- Collision damage caused by attendants
- Comprehensive events (fire, vandalism, weather) while vehicles are parked
- Theft of the vehicle
What to verify:
- Per-vehicle coverage limits (should meet or exceed the value of vehicles you typically park)
- Aggregate limits (total coverage across all incidents in a policy period)
- Deductible amounts (who pays the deductible — the valet company or the property?)
General Liability
Protects against bodily injury and property damage claims not related to vehicle handling:
- A guest trips at the valet stand
- An attendant damages property infrastructure
- A bystander is injured during valet operations
Standard coverage starts at $1 million per occurrence with $2 million aggregate. High-volume operations should carry higher limits.
Commercial Auto Insurance
Covers the valet company's liability while attendants are driving guest vehicles. This is separate from garage-keeper liability, which covers parked vehicles.
Key distinction: Garage-keeper liability covers the vehicle while parked. Commercial auto covers the vehicle while being driven by the attendant.
Workers' Compensation
Required in most states. Covers valet attendants injured on the job — sprains from running, injuries from slippery conditions, or accidents while parking vehicles.
If the valet company doesn't carry workers' comp, injured attendants could file claims against the property owner.
Hired and Non-Owned Auto
Covers liability when attendants drive vehicles they don't own (which is every guest vehicle). This fills gaps between garage-keeper liability and commercial auto coverage.
What Properties Should Require
When contracting with a valet company, require the following documentation:
Certificate of Insurance (COI)
A formal document from the valet company's insurer listing:
- Policy types and coverage limits
- Policy effective dates
- Additional insured status (see below)
Additional Insured Endorsement
This is critical. An additional insured endorsement names your property on the valet company's policy. If a guest sues both you and the valet company, the valet company's insurance responds on your behalf too.
Always require this. A valet company that can't provide additional insured status is a red flag.
Minimum Coverage Limits
For most commercial properties, require at least:
| Coverage Type | Minimum Limit | |---|---| | Garage-Keeper Liability | $1,000,000 per occurrence | | General Liability | $1,000,000 per occurrence / $2,000,000 aggregate | | Commercial Auto | $1,000,000 combined single limit | | Workers' Compensation | Statutory limits |
For luxury properties or venues that regularly handle high-value vehicles, increase garage-keeper limits to $2,000,000 or higher.
You might also be interested in our guide to luxury dealership valet standards.
Hold Harmless / Indemnification Agreement
A contractual provision where the valet company agrees to indemnify the property owner for losses arising from valet operations. This works alongside insurance to protect the property.
Common Insurance Pitfalls
Pitfall 1: Assuming Your Property Insurance Covers Valet
Your commercial property insurance likely excludes vehicles in the care of third-party operators. If a valet company damages a guest's car and doesn't have proper insurance, the guest sues you.
Pitfall 2: Not Verifying Coverage Annually
Insurance policies expire. A COI from last year means nothing today. Require updated certificates annually and set calendar reminders to verify.
Pitfall 3: Inadequate Limits for High-Value Vehicles
If your venue hosts events where Porsche Cayennes and Tesla Model S vehicles are common, $500,000 in garage-keeper coverage is insufficient. One totaled luxury vehicle could exhaust the policy.
Pitfall 4: No Excess or Umbrella Coverage
For large-scale operations (hotels, hospitals, corporate campuses), an umbrella policy provides additional coverage beyond primary policy limits. This is your safety net for catastrophic claims.
Pitfall 5: Ignoring Subcontractor Coverage
Some valet companies subcontract to staffing agencies. If the person parking your guests' cars is a subcontractor, verify that coverage extends to subcontracted workers.
The Claims Process
When an incident occurs, a clear claims process minimizes friction:
Immediate Steps
- Document the damage — photos, video, and written descriptions at the scene
- Notify the valet company — formal written notification within 24 hours
- Collect guest information — contact details, vehicle information, their insurance details
- File a police report — if theft, collision with another vehicle, or significant damage
The Resolution Path
- Guest files claim with the valet company
- Valet company notifies their insurer
- Insurer assigns an adjuster who contacts the guest
- Damage is assessed and repair costs are determined
- Payment is issued to the guest or repair facility
Professional valet companies handle this process proactively. The property should not need to manage claims — that's the valet company's responsibility.
Risk Mitigation Beyond Insurance
Insurance is a safety net, not a strategy. The best protection is preventing incidents:
Attendant Training
- Proper vehicle handling techniques
- Speed limits within the lot (5 mph or walking speed)
- Mirror and seat adjustment protocols
- Documenting pre-existing damage before parking
Technology
- Digital check-in photos — time-stamped images of every vehicle at drop-off
- GPS tracking — monitor vehicle location and attendant driving behavior
- Key management systems — secure, tracked key storage
Operational Standards
- Walk-around inspections with the guest present
- Defined parking routes to minimize reversing
- Weather protocols for rain, ice, and snow conditions
- Maximum vehicle-to-attendant ratios
For a look at how these standards apply in high-value contexts, see our article on classic car show valet.
Questions to Ask Your Valet Provider
Before signing a contract, ask these questions:
- Can you provide a current Certificate of Insurance? (If they hesitate, walk away.)
- Will you add our property as an additional insured? (Non-negotiable.)
- What are your garage-keeper liability limits? (Match to the vehicles your guests drive.)
- How do you handle claims? (They should have a documented process.)
- Are your attendants W-2 employees or subcontractors? (Affects coverage and liability.)
- What is your incident documentation process? (Should include photos and written reports.)
- Do you carry umbrella/excess liability? (Important for large-scale operations.)
- What is your safety record? (Ask for incident rates and claims history.)
The Cost of Being Uninsured
A single valet incident without proper insurance can cost:
- Vehicle repair: $2,000 - $15,000 for body work
- Vehicle replacement: $30,000 - $100,000+ for total loss
- Legal defense: $10,000 - $50,000+ in attorney fees
- Settlement: $25,000 - $250,000+ depending on severity
- Reputation damage: Incalculable
Proper valet insurance costs a fraction of one uninsured claim. It's not an expense — it's a prerequisite.
FAQ
Q: Does the guest's personal auto insurance cover valet damage? A: Usually, no. Most personal auto policies exclude damage that occurs while the vehicle is in the care of a commercial operator. The valet company's garage-keeper policy is the primary coverage.
Q: What if the valet company goes out of business after an incident? A: This is why additional insured status matters. As an additional insured, you can file directly with their insurer even if the company ceases operations.
Q: Are electric vehicles covered the same as gas vehicles? A: Generally yes, but EV battery damage can be exceptionally expensive to repair. Ensure garage-keeper limits account for the higher repair costs associated with EVs.
Q: Should I require proof of insurance from valet companies bidding on our contract? A: Absolutely. Request COIs during the bidding process, not after you've selected a vendor. It's a baseline qualification, not an afterthought.
Open Door Valet: Great Service, Everywhere, All the Time.
Request a quote for professionally insured valet parking service.